Better-than-Pumpkin Cushaw Pie [REVISED – Now with low glycemic option]

Most definitely not very pie-ish on the outside.

I know what you’re thinking.  This does not look like the basis for a better-than-pumpkin pie.  I wish someone would explain to me how this funny, pot-bellied, green-and-white-striped squash has heretofore escaped my food bank.  Or why it has not overtaken pumpkin in the pie category.  It is really that good.

My farmer, Stacey Roussel, is a Louisiana girl.  She first mentioned this squash to me when I was interviewing her for an article.  Stacey’s grandmother cooked by the seasons, so a cushaw squash pie will forever take Stacey back to her grandmother’s kitchen, in a house surrounded by Louisiana sugar cane fields.  Any squash that stirs that kind of memory is one I want to try, so when I spied this beauty at the Sugar Land Farmer’s Market, I scooped it up, aching arms be damned.  (Any suggestions for a portable cart?)  If I’d have known then just how great it would be, I’d have risked shoulder dislocation and bought them all.

So what exactly is this cushaw?  Also known as a kershaw or a Tennessee sweet potato squash, it is a crook-necked member of the Cucurbitaceae family.  It is very heat tolerant, so much so that it can also be planted in the spring.  It has a long history with the Native Americans and later found its way into the kitchens of the south, especially in Louisiana, Tennessee, and Mississippi.  You can still find cushaw pie as a menu item in some New Orlean’s restaurants.  [I recently made this recipe using a Long of Naples squash — results were fantastic as well.]

Cut up before roasting

I have nearly chopped off my hand cutting up a butternut, yet I sliced through the cushaw with ease, almost like slicing through a summer squash.  This was a relief.  Hacking away at a hard, unbalanced object is not my favorite part of cooking with winter squash.  Despite this softer skin, it surprisingly keeps a very long time if kept in a dark, cool place.   Yet another reason I will buy a bunch at one time if I see them again!  I might even try planting them, but my history of success in gardening is rather sketchy (remember the ‘pretend’ in my moniker?)

There are several different ways to prepare winter squash for recipes but I really have only two ways I like to make it.  If I am going to use the squash in baking or soups, roasting is the way to go.  If I want the squash to hold its shape, say in a pasta dish, salad, or quesadilla, grilling is my choice.  Both methods bring out the rich taste of fall, but steaming, microwaving, or boiling really do nothing to enhance the squash, and even dilute the flavor, in my opinion.

For the pie, I searched for recipes and finally adapted one I found from Chickens in the Road.  I was attracted to her recipe because she had already done the leg work of finding one best suited to the flavor of the cushaw.  Regular pumpkin pie recipes called for too much sugar, which would drown the cushaw flavor.   I did make a few changes though, like using heavy cream instead of evaporated milk (which I have a hard time trusting…and besides, why use anything else when you have cream?)  Bewarned…this recipe will be of a softer consistency when you use cream.  That is something I accept and even prefer, but if you are looking for perfect slices of pie that don’t slouch when cut, you may want to use the evaporated milk. [UPDATE:  This Thanksgiving, I actually took the time to let the extra water drain from the puree in a strainer.  Forget the above comments about evaporated milk.  The cream version was perfectly firm…I am a dedicated fan of the strainer now.]

I found this pie to be so much better than pumpkin, that I’m afraid that I have ruined my taste for the Libby’s classic.  Only one kid out of five said that pumpkin pie was better.  There is so much depth to this pie.  Rich spicyness, perfectly squashy, balanced sweetness…I just can’t imagine why this is not more widespread.  Here’s to heirloom growers!!!

I’ve now included a low glycemic option. I find that when I eat cane sugar, I crave more and more sugar. If I use a low-glycemic sugar, like coconut palm sugar, I am not turned into a sugar beast.  Since going low/no cane sugar, we all prefer my new version with only a 1/3 cup sugar. It’s sweet enough to qualify as dessert, but not overwhelmingly sweet.

Pureed, roasted cushaw squash. It’s very light in color.

Better-than-Pumpkin Cushaw Pie (adapted from Suzanne McMinn)

The Crust:

Prepare your favorite recipe for pie crust.  My pictures don’t show any crust.  I usually only go to the trouble of making a gluten-free pie crust at Thanksgiving and Christmas.  The reward of flavor/texture aren’t equal to the time and expense, in my opinion.  When I do make crust, I’ve had the best success using the King Arthur recipe for Gluten-Free Pie Crust.

Preparing the Cushaw:

Preheat oven to 375 F.  Wash and cut the cushaw, spread out on a roasting pan, cover and bake for an hour or so, checking for tenderness.  Cushaws will shred even when well roasted, much like a spaghetti squash, but don’t worry.  A quick swirl in a food processor will puree the cushaw to a lovely consistency.

Taste it’s pure flavor straight from the oven. A real treat.

You will have enough cushaw to enjoy a few chunks straight from the oven with just a little butter and a sprinkle of salt.  Even my three-year old couldn’t resist.  If you’ve ever choked down an acorn squash just to be polite, I promise, this is a completely different experience.

This next step is optional, although I recommend it.  Sometimes I don’t do it because I am impatient, but if you like a tighter custard filling, you can take your puree and pour it into cheesecloth or tight strainer suspended over a bowl.  Drain the puree until thickened.  Think canned pumpkin consistency and you’ll know when it’s ready. I’ve tried this recipe with great success using other winter squashes, such as the Long of Naples squash, and some absolutely require straining. Each squash varies in its natural water content…the Long of Naples is extremely high in water.

The Pie:

Turn your oven to 350 F.

It looked exactly like applesauce.

2 cups prepared cushaw squash puree, drained
2/3 cup brown sugar [For a low-glycemic pie, use 1/3 cup coconut sugar only –it’s perfectly sweetened]
1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon ground ginger
1/2 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
3 large eggs
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 1/4 cup heavy cream [I’ve been reducing this to 1 cup for a firmer pie]
pastry for single-crust pie

Combine cushaw squash puree, brown sugar [or coconut sugar], cinnamon, ginger, salt, nutmeg, and cloves in the bowl of a stand mixer or a medium sized bowl.  Add eggs and vanilla then beat lightly with the whisk attachment or with a hand whisk.  Stir in heavy cream.  Mix well.  Pour into a pastry-lined pie plate.  Bake on the lowest oven rack at 350-degrees for 60 minutes (until a knife blade or toothpick comes out clean). I usually look at the pie at 60 minutes — if the top hasn’t puffed up all the way, it needs more time. Chill before serving to firm up.  Or if you’re like me, you can eat it warm and soft.  It is said that pumpkin-y pies taste better the next day but with seven eaters in my house, we’ll never know.

Depth, spicy, balanced sweetness.

About Jill Thaxton

Wife, mom, writer, cook, professional Googler. I can't seem to narrow my interests to one topic, but love to ponder people, culture, faith, health, food, relationships, and science. I specialize in minutiae. Oh, and I will forever regret quitting piano, in case you were interested.
This entry was posted in eating local, Gluten Free, Recipes for Fall, Recipes for Spring, Recipes for Winter and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

19 Responses to Better-than-Pumpkin Cushaw Pie [REVISED – Now with low glycemic option]

  1. OfBaking says:

    I’ve seen these at the farmer’s market and had no idea what to do with them! I can’t wait to try this!

  2. sahfoodie says:

    I’ve never seen these before. But, if my experiments with other squash is anything, it’s probably delicious in bread and pie.

  3. Never seen this type of squash, but I will keep an eye out for it. Your post has peaked some interest because I like trying new things! Thanks for sharing.

  4. blisschick says:

    My granny used to cook these down like sweet potatoes and we’d eat it in chunks, scraping it off the rind. I grew some this summer and am going to try making a pie from my biggest one. My mouth is already watering!

  5. Bre says:

    if you’re in Ga you can find these at Burt’s Farm in Dawsonville. I just bought a 29lb one for $5. That is going to make a lot of pies, soup, and bread!

  6. trytoolose says:

    Looking for pumpkins found these green stripes on wagon @ end of driveway sale. Bought for ornamental, but looked them up to find out if edibles. What a delicious surprise! Been growing huge ones from those original seeds since.

  7. Mary Winicker says:

    I have been growing many squash including Tennessee Sweet Potato squash for a number of years. I have grown the Cushaws because of their beauty, but have mostly read that they were not good eats. I have successfully dried a few Tennessee Sweet Potato squash…love the corky stems with ridges running downward. You have persuaded me to try one in a pie this fall. I make squash(usually) or pumpkin (Thanksgiving) pie at least weekly from October to the following spring. I like to use the gray hubbard/maxima squash such as Sweet Meat or Grey Ghost or the pumpkin-like Galeux d’Eysine. My new favorite is a small buttercup called Uncle David’s Dakota Dessert. I use Winter Luxury for pies for Thanksgiving.
    It was nice to find someone who makes the squash pie with a recipe similar to mine, which I owe to Stephen Scmidt from Master Recipes. I use less cream (1 cup) with 3 eggs, similar sugar and spices and a bit of allspice as well. (Schmidt uses a cup of sugar…I use 3/4) I also learned to drain the puree, using a fine linen towel or even just a fine mesh strainer. I sometimes put the flesh through a food mill. I use heavy cream that is not ultra-pasteurized which takes away much of the flavor. I think squash pies are generally much tastier than pies made with pie pumpkins.

  8. Pam Green says:

    I grew Cushaw Sqaush last summer, they grow well in central Florida. Made this pie last week – delicious! Making another today, really good recipe.

    • teresa tilton says:

      I buy my Cushaws at Burt’s every year and bring home to Fla. I love my cushaw pies. I’ll
      never go back to pumpkin.

  9. Desiree says:

    I got my first one at an Amish produce stand. It weighed at least 10 pounds and was only $2. The other day I got 2 more for $1 and $2. They’re amazingly delicious. They’re not heard of much and cheap.

  10. Deborah Strawser says:

    My grandmother grew these as well. She grew up in Kentucky but had Tennessee Cherokee linage. This was her preferred squash. I don’t remember her ever baking a pumpkin pie. I planted some seed this past summer but only got one nice sized squash and I plan to bake it for Thanksgiving. I live in Tennessee and it did take the summer heat well. I plan to grow it again next summer. I bought my seeds from Baker Farm heirloom seeds. Grow these! You won’t be sorry.

  11. Bex says:

    Can you use pumpkin pie spice instead? I have one that has everything in it this recipe calls for. (And it doesn’t contain allspice, like some do.)

  12. Bob says:

    I tried several recipes for cushaw pie and this one was the best! I grow them in my garden every year and make pies or cook them like a butternut squash as a side dish- cubed and sprinkled with brown sugar and butter and then baked till tender.

  13. Sue says:

    I planted these seeds thinking I was growing butternut squash. I have 12 llaarrggee squash waiting for me to finish processing all the summer veggies. I think this pie will be a worthy reward for my hard work!

  14. Maria says:

    I have planted and grown cushaw and am gonna try your delicious pie recipe. I have one question tho…. you mentioned cutting the cushaw to roast it, but you didn’t mention how to cut it. Do you cut it in small pieces? Or what length did you cut it? Thanks for the recipe, can’t wait to try it!

  15. Jill Thaxton says:

    I recently bought a Long of Naples Squash and used it for this recipe. The squash easily yielded 18 cups of puree!! That’s a lot of squash! And pie!

  16. Sandra says:

    Thanks for this post!!! I received s pack from my seed of the month club and I am like ok what do I do with this!! We love pumpkin pie so now I am truly psyched to give this a go! So can I plant now? Thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s